Rating System:
**** : Excellent
*** : Good
** : Fair
* : Poor
Zero : Horse Shit

Zatanna #1

I was really looking forward to this book, I’ve always been a fan of Zatanna, not just that she is sexy as hell in a top hat and fishnet stockings, I like her personality and powerset. With Dr. Strange seemingly reduced to guest-star status in the Marvel universe I was looking to Zatanna to fill my magic superhero fix for the time being.

After reading the first issue of Paul Dini and Stephane Roux comic I might just wait for Dr. Strange’s return to a mainstream book. The first issue finds Zatanna performing in her nightly magic show, after the show she is contacted by a local police detective to help in the investigation of some occult murders and by the end of the comic is taking a hot bubble bath. And that’s pretty much it story wise…OK, I am not being very fair, Zatanna agrees to help and pretty quickly figures out who is behind the murders and goes to confront the bad guy involved. The comic was a pretty quick read and there just wasn’t a whole lot of meat to the story. I don’t know if years of ‘Buffy the Vampire Slayer’ has left me jaded to the whole demons in suits running a criminal enterprise storyline, but the whole story DID feel like an episode of Buffy, minus the sharp dialog and likable characters. Dini tries hard to make Zatanna a wisecracking bad-ass, but his efforts mostly fall flat. Only the scene with Zatanna crashing the bad guy party has some life to it, but it was to little, too late to help the story. Dini seems to spend too much time trying to write one-liners and not enough time on plot, which seems to move too haphazardly at times.

The art by Stephane Roux was fine, if uneven at times, unfortunately, J.H. Williams III doing the art here would not have saved this very average story. However, this was the first issue, so I will give Zatanna at least one more issue before I bail.

Rating: **

Atlas #1

Ok, first off I actually did enjoy this issue, let me just get that out of the way before I make a few complaints here. Jeff Parker is the ‘Man” as far as writing super group books are concerned, I think he is the best in the biz right now at writing funny, exciting dialog and smart, well structured battles. It this group dynamic that I enjoy so much in a Jeff Parker book that left me wanting in this first issue of the Atlas relaunch.

The majority of this first comic focus mostly on one character, 3-D Man. Is there anything wrong with 3-D Man? No, not really, Parker does a fine job of writing the back-story to fill in the history of Delroy Garret. I don’t know if I find him a very compelling character just yet, I am sure in the future I will enjoy this new member of Atlas (well, not yet, but he will be). I guess my question is why even add 3-D Man to the team, does Atlas even need another member right now? I think Atlas was perfectly balanced as it was, and I do think the spending so much time bring Delroy into the fold took a bit of wind out of the sails of this relaunch. I really wanted a full book with the whole team involved in some action on the behalf of the Atlas Foundation, that is where the Atlas really shines, the whole group working together to get themselves out of a jam or working to do good, while seeming so bad. Atlas does show up at the end of the book as a team, but it is only for a few pages and it served to remind me just how much I wanted to see them throughout the whole book. I wish that Jeff Parker would have switched the page count on the stories, giving 3-D man the backup story and keep our group on heroes active in the main story. The book ends with some filler that wasn’t much to look at, a written history of 3-D that wasn’t really needed.

Gabriel Hardman’s art is starting to grow on me, I really like his rough style, but I do wish they would lighten up on colors, the pages get very dark at times, making it hard to see what is going on.

I really did like this book a lot, and I enjoyed 3-D Man’s story, I just think that 3-D man could have waited a couple of issues at make his appearance. I wanted to see my Agents back in action, not relegated to the back up story in their own book.

Rating: ***

The Invincible Iron Man #26

Tony Stark continues to perform rehab on himself and his company in this latest issue. Thankfully there is only a brief appearance by the Hammer Girls and their somewhat tired story in this issue and it concentrates on Tony trying to make right with some of the people he screwed over back in the day. It is interesting that Fraction isn’t giving Tony the easy way out on this deal, so far Tony hasn’t had much luck getting forgiveness from his former friends and allies. In some cases Tony actually makes things worse for himself by being a little too honest about being such an arrogant asshole in the past. Tony Stark actually talks himself out of some of the good will he was getting from Maria Hill as he tries to explain why he still may need someone there to make sure he doesn’t spin out of control again. In another case Tony goes back to an old employee that he humiliated and fired some time back, Fraction does a great job here writing Carson Wyche, the wronged employee, he doesn’t scream or rage at his old boss, hell he doesn’t even seem that mad anymore, but he is a broken man, resigned to his fate. Watching Tony try at makes amends to a man that really couldn’t give a shit one way or another anymore was painful to watch.

Another gem in this book was the return of one of my favorite Iron Man villains, Spymaster. It’s nice to see him back, but what is up with that costume? I know he is an asshole, but do you really have to put two giant pink sphincters on either side of his head? I wonder if Tony has any idea so many of his old enemies are piling up, getting in line for a chance to take a shot at him.

One thing about this book that did bug me was the art, or the reusing of some of the panels from the last issue and some of the panels that are recycled from within the same issue. I know it isn’t uncommon for artist to reuse some of their work to save time, but it was done a lot in this issue and enough that it started to bug me after awhile. Almost two full pages of the Detroit Steel panels from last issue where reused here in issue #26. The Tony/Hill conversation reuses many of the same panels from different angles and zooms.

Artwork nitpicks aside, this was an enjoyable issue that left me wondering just how long Fraction is going to let Tony twist in the wind before he lets him have his redemption. I just hope it doesn’t happen too fast, I am taking a bit of pleasure in Tony pain right now. Sometimes heroes are at their best when they are taking their lumps.

Rating: ***½

American Vampire #3

My favorite book of the week. I really like how Scott Snyder and Stephen King are shaping up their vampire mythology here. The European Vampires vs. The American Vampires is turning into a far more enjoyable story that I would have thought at first. Even though there are only two American Vampires they have the advantage in this battle due to the fact they are very different from their European cousins. My favorite scene in the book was the Euro Vamp’s attempting to figure out just what hell they can do to take down Skinner Sweet. I also liked the fact that there are no good guys or bad guys in this story so far. It’s tempting to make Sweet the good guy here, but Stephen King makes it very clear that he is a vicious killing machine that is more than willing to kill everyone in his path, whether it be for revenge, hunger or just because he is a total asshole. Even Pearl, the innocent victim in the first two book takes to killing rather quickly and makes you wonder if she was all that innocent to begin with.

I know some people don’t like Rafael Albuquerque’s art, but I think it fits the mood of the book very well, and anyone who can take Kid Rock and make him scary looking gets two thumbs up from me.

I never thought I would be putting a vampire book back into my top five list, but it is starting to look that way. I will reserve judgment on this title until after King leaves the book and see if still maintains it’s level of quality.

Rating: ***½

  1. phil says:

    Zatanna…I’m curious about, if only for the art. After seeing Steph’s cover work on B o P and I think S6, I’m interested in how she tackles panel compisition.

    A o A I’ve never warmed to and that was when the masterful pencils of Carlo Pagulayan were gracing the pages. The fact that you’ve mentioned that there’s an artist with a rough style drawing the comic, I’m sure that’ll further distance me from Atlas.

    Well IM, I.M. 2 did nothing to make me want to pick up the comic.

    VG17 spoke very highly of this comic as well. I looked thru it and while there was nothing I could say was glaringly wrong with it; the Non-Sequtor meets old fashioned clothing design ads just did not appeal to me

    Hopefully I’ll see something in Z that you didn’t, if not….well I was never that big a fan of magic, anyway 🙂

    • IronMuskrat says:

      I would be lying if I said I liked Hardman’s work over Pagulayan. But Hardman’s stuff has a bit of a retro feel to it, that fits with a lot of the jumping between time periods that Jeff Parker likes to do.

      However, if it were announced tomorrow that Pagulayan was coming back to the book, I would be very happy. =)

  2. Deemar says:

    I really enjoyed Atlas and the art was pretty damn amazing, coloring and all.

    I agree Musky there was a little too much 3D Man, but I understand why he’s going this route. Parker is giving us a Delroy primer (Which would have been better as a one-shot) either way I liked it and will continue to buy Atlas.

    • IronMuskrat says:

      I don’t mind 3D Man, I guess my question is why push him so hard right from the start. For me the Atlas lineup was fine to start with, if you want to add a new guy to the mix, that’s cool, but don’t forget that really cool team that already out there.

      For me it would be like doing a relaunch of the Avengers, but the entire first issue is about there newest member, Paladin or some other hero coming into the mix.

      That said, Parker always delivers and I trust he will pull this one out.

      • kurumais says:

        well as fans we wanted the agents back as is, hoping that the book would pick up right where it left off, but what would be the point of marvel sending out the same AoA when they weren’t selling? the fact that it got relaunched at all with the same writer is a minor miracle.
        3D man was in he original what if story im sure parker and the crew have gotten a lot “why didnt you have 3D man in the book questions?”
        after a couple of reading i think he is fitting him in nicely plus keeping the agents
        hint of disreputable going by adding delroy as persona non grata in the SH community

  3. Deemar says:

    Great reviews Musky

    Always a pleasure


  4. Mike F says:

    I completely agree with you on Zatanna. I have waitied for this book for a while and I love Zatanna More than any other female DC hero.

    Fuck Paul Dini. The Last 3 comics I’ve bought by him were so shit, I felt tempted to demand a refund.

    • IronMuskrat says:

      I know Mike, Dini’s stuff use to impress me, but Zatanna #1 was a real disappointment for me.


      • Deemar says:

        I’ve given up on Dini awhile ago.

        • SMARTASS8 says:

          I gave up on Paul Dini after the first season He-Man & The Masters Of The Universe episode “Prince Adam No More”.


      • Mike F says:

        Yeah I realized Dini is bad after Gothan City Sirens.

        • kurumais says:

          i was so psyched when the folks that did all those great animated DC shows were going to start writing comics. the justice league cartoon was as good a take on that team as any i ever read. but so far non of the folks associated with have done very good comics.
          they should go back and do a secret origins series for cartoon network. do those old great one and done origin stories for a bunch of the dcu heroes and villains.

  5. J.H. Williams would SO rock on Zantanna!

  6. Locusmortis says:

    Nice Reviews IM,

    I pretty much had the same opinion on Zatanna, just a bit underwhelmed by it, I’m not mad on Roux’s art either.

    I might trade wait American Vampire, I’m a bit vampired out at the moment lol

    • kurumais says:

      im with you on the vamps loc they are EVERYWHERE these days and now we starting to get zombies all over the place

  7. Variant Girl says:

    I really enjoyed your reviews. I agree with you on Atlas #1, love Jeff Parker but 3-D man, aeh, not so much. I liked the issue but it was certainly not one of my favourites in the series. Keep up the good work 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s